• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

Enchanting Marketing

Writing advice for small business

  • Home
  • Blog
  • Books & Courses
  • Mugs
  • About
  • Contact
  • Free Writing Course

The Curiosity Gap: Can You Entice More People to Click and Read?

by Henneke | 58 enchanting opinions, add yours? :)

The curiosity gap is the space between the information we’re given and the information initially withheld. By highlighting this gap in knowledge, writers make readers curious to learn more.

This article discusses:

What is the curiosity gap?
How to open up the curiosity gap
Email subject lines that arouse curiosity
Email examples that make people click
Headlines that open the curiosity gap
The curiosity gap in non-fiction writing

How to open up the curiosity gap

how to open up the curiosity gap - explanation + examplesThis happened to me recently.

I had written a blog post and carefully crafted an email. I hit publish with a sigh of relief. Done.

But when I looked at my email stats the next day, the results were disappointing. The opens were fine. So my subject line had been good. But the clickthroughs? Rather depressing.

What was the problem?

I had forgotten to open up the curiosity gap in my email. Sure, avid readers still clicked to read, but others? I had not given them a strong enough incentive to click through.

By opening up the curiosity gap, you can get more people to open and click your emails, get more social media followers to click and read your blog posts, and you can keep people reading your blog posts, articles, and non-fiction books.

The curiosity gap is one of the most powerful tools in marketing.

Let me explain …

What is the curiosity gap?

The curiosity gap is the space between the information we’re given (what we know) and the information that’s initially withheld (what we don’t know).

By highlighting this gap in knowledge, writers and marketers make readers aware of their lack of knowledge and readers become curious to learn more.

How to open up the curiosity gap

Curiosity has a bad name because we often associate curiosity with nosiness and clickbait titles, such as:

  • Being a new dad almost broke him — until one moment changed everything. (Upworthy)
  • A dad dressed as Darth Vader to wake up his son. The kid’s reaction is pure ‘Star Wars.’ (Upworthy)
  • A rover dived to the bottom of the ocean. 15 photos show what it found there. (Upworthy)
  • A homeless man was tried for stealing $4.50 worth of food. Here’s what the judges said. (Upworthy)
  • The biggest circus lion rescue of its kind just happened, and it was epic. (Upworthy)

These titles make us click by opening up a curiosity gap.

How?

First they share a piece of information, then they highlight something we don’t know yet so we itch to click and find out more.

A piece of information:
A homeless man was tried for stealing $4.50 worth of food

The gap in knowledge making us itch to find out more:
Here’s what the judges said

A piece of information:
The biggest circus lion rescue of its kind just happened

The gap in knowledge making us itch to find out more:
And it was epic

The gap in knowledge makes us impatient to learn more. What did the judges say? Why was that rescue so epic?

In his book Curious: The Desire to Know and Why Your Future Depends on It, Ian Leslie calls this diversive curiosity: “the restless desire for the new and the next.”

This type of curiosity is quite superficial as the search for information is aimless and impulsive. It’s gossipy.

The second type of curiosity is different.

Leslie calls it epistemic curiosity: “a quest for knowledge and understanding.”

This type of curiosity requires more effort, a deeper dive into a topic. Instead of making us impatient, it nourishes our soul.

As we’ve seen you can open up the curiosity gap by sharing a bit of gossip and making people curious to know more. But you can open up the curiosity gap by appealing to people’s quest for real knowledge, their hunger for wisdom and inspiration.

Here’s how …

Email subject lines that arouse curiosity

By arousing curiosity in your subject line, you encourage people to open your email.

Here’s an example:

A pain-free copywriting process: 5 key questions you must answer

How does this subject line open up a curiosity gap?

The first part refers to a desire many writers have: making the copywriting process pain-free.

The second part of the subject line creates curiosity: Which 5 key questions must be answered?

Here’s another example of the curiosity gap in an email subject line:

Do You Know This #1 Fiction Writing Trick For Compelling Business Content?

How does this open up the curiosity gap?

This subject line appeals to people’s desire for creating compelling business content; and it arouses curiosity by referring to the #1 fiction writing trick. Which trick is this about?

Here’s one more example of a subject line that opens the curiosity gap:

Free Copywriting Webinar on Thursday – details inside

This subject line gives 3 pieces of information:there’s a copywriting webinar, it’s on Thursday, and it’s free.

But at what time is the webinar? And what is it exactly about?

The subject line suggests that the details are inside—a nudge to open the email to learn more.

Email examples that make people click

The first step in email marketing is to get people to open your emails. The next step is to get them to read your email and then click on a link.

To get more clicks, you can reinforce the curiosity gap in your email or even open it up a tad more.

Here’s an example:

Subject line: This writing is so so soooo good …

Sometimes, I read something that’s so good …

And I can’t wait to share it with you.

Discover why I like this piece of writing so much >>

I hope you’re okay.

Warmest wishes,
Henneke 🖤

PS The tips in the post are useful for almost any type of writing, no matter whether you’re writing sales copy, blog posts, or even fiction. Have a sneak peek here.

Why does this email open up the curiosity gap?

The short subject line refers to an incredibly good piece of writing (But which piece of writing??? Please let me knooooow!).

The email text reinforces the curiosity gap by confirming that this writing example is so good that the sender can’t wait to share this.

The email raises two questions that arouse curiosity: Which piece of writing? And why is it so good?

The word discover is a power word, associated with satisfying your curiosity. Who doesn’t like discovering something new?

The PS reassures you that no matter what type of writing you’re interested in, this writing example will be useful.

Who can resist?

Another way to open up the curiosity gap in an email

Here’s another example email:

Subject line: Good writing? These 11 favorite sentences show you how …

What are the hallmarks of a good sentence?

I recently set out on a “journey” to find out.

I mostly read books on Kindle, and when I come across a good sentence, I highlight it. I’ve done this for years.

But I don’t always look back at what I’ve highlighted.

So, I wondered …

What would I discover if I traveled through my highlighted sentences?

Read my 11 favorite sentences and discover what you can learn >>

Happy writing,
Henneke

PS Looking for a book recommendation? This post includes 7 books I loved. Have a sneak peek here

This email tells a little story about a journey through my Kindle highlights and the discovery of 11 favorite sentences. That’s the information you get.

And the curiosity gap is opened by the questions: Which are those 11 favorite sentences? And what can we learn from them?

If that doesn’t arouse enough curiosity to click through, the PS opens up another gap by suggesting the post includes 7 book recommendations. But which? You need to click to get a sneak peek. The phrase sneak peek makes the effort of satisfying your curiosity seem low.

Headlines that open the curiosity gap

A good headline arouses curiosity.

But some arouse more curiosity than others.

Here’s an example:

We Tested 4 Famous Pizza Dough Recipes — And 1 *Really* Stood Out (The Kitchn)

The piece of information you get is that 4 famous pizza dough recipes were tested.

But which one stood really out?

If you like baking pizza it’s be useful to find out which dough recipe was the best.

Here’s another example:

This Is What Happens When Employees Find Meaning at Work (Entrepreneur)

This is a good headline formula for opening the curiosity gap. The piece of information you get is that employees find meaning at work. But what happened next?

One more headline example:

Do You Really Need That Exclamation Point? (HubSpot)

When we ask a burning question that plays in our audience’s minds, people want to click to find out the answer.

The curiosity gap in non-fiction writing

I used to think that writing blog posts simply means sharing information.

But information itself is not enough.

To keep people reading, we need to keep them curious to learn more.

One way to do this is to ask questions in our writing, and another way is to use cliffhangers.

For instance, in her book River Kings, archeologist Cat Jarman describes receiving an orange bead that was discovered in a Viking grave in Repton, Derbyshire (UK). She uses a cliffhanger to make readers curious:

I didn’t know it at the time, but this bead would take my search for the Vikings in a whole new direction and radically change my understanding of the Viking Age.

A cliffhanger makes readers curious by raising questions in their minds. How did her understanding of the Viking Age change so radically and why? What’s so special about this orange bead?

Jarman also describes the bead and the questions it raises for her:

To me, there was something compelling about that tiny bead. The smooth, almost translucent material; the sharply cut corners; the faceted shape with angles that looked so perfect and so modern. I couldn’t help but obsess over all the hands, all the lives, that it had intersected with over more than a millennium including, now, my own. Who had it belonged to? Was it dropped accidentally, or placed in the mass grave deliberately? How did it end up in Repton and were there other links to the east there that we had not previously considered – could this be a major new discovery?

Raising questions makes readers curious—they want answers, and that’s why they keep reading on. It works the same in fiction and non-fiction whether you’re writing a crime novel, a science book, a tutorial, or an educational blog post.

We live in a world of instant answers

Want to know how to repair a puncture? How to create a formula in Excel? How to create an image using Canva?

We google a question and instantly find an answer.

Are we losing our ability to dive deep into a topic?

A few years ago, I had temporarily lost the ability to read a difficult book. It’s embarrassing to admit it. But I was tired. I was restless. And overwhelmed.

By managing distractions and my energy level, I slowly regained the ability to concentrate. To read rather than skim books.

My curiosity was rekindled, and life became more fascinating, more colorful again.

As bloggers, we are mentors for our readers

Instant answers are useful to help readers get unstuck.

But it’s the deepening of knowledge and sharing of our skills where the magic happens.

I like to think each of your blog posts can cause a teeny-tiny ripple. A tip that makes life a bit better. A dash of inspiration. A feeling of connection.

Let’s not chase clicks.

Let’s tickle curiosity to share knowledge with our readers.

PS

This blog post was originally published on 31 May 2016. An expanded and revised version was published on 18 November 2021.

Recommended reading on curiosity and other ways to keep readers engaged:

How to hook readers with cliffhangers
10 headline formulas that attract readers
How to craft blog newsletters (and gain more readers)

Share
Share

Enjoyed this? Get my fortnightly newsletter in your inbox > > >

Get my best writing tips in your inbox ...

Success! Now check your email to confirm your subscription.

There was an error submitting your subscription. Please try again.

Powered by ConvertKit

Reader Interactions

Share
Share

Leave a comment and join the conversation Cancel reply

Comments

  1. Patricia Ballard says

    October 19, 2018 at 10:55 pm

    As a fiction writer, how could you do this to me? WHAT IS THE #1 FICTION WRITER TRICK????????? I’m at the ending of my book and having an awful time, painful time, I’m suffering. …….

    Reply
    • Henneke says

      October 22, 2018 at 8:55 pm

      I’m so sorry to read you’re having a painful time finishing your book. Writing a book can be so tough!

      Reply
  2. Faizan says

    June 15, 2018 at 11:16 am

    Many gems unfolded in this piece of content. Truly recommendable article.
    By using this curiosity gap, I hope to have growth in Open rate and CRT. Thanks for sharing this content.

    Reply
    • Henneke says

      June 16, 2018 at 12:21 pm

      It really works!

      Reply
  3. Marina Monciatti says

    March 31, 2018 at 12:08 pm

    Wow, very useful not only for marketing but for any other type of job too. Thank you for the article 🙂

    Reply
    • Henneke says

      March 31, 2018 at 7:47 pm

      Thank you, Marina. 🙂

      Reply
  4. Singaravelu A.P says

    June 21, 2016 at 2:33 pm

    Yes Henneke, I got the curiosity to learn more and write frequently.

    Thanks for your article Henneke, We love you.
    🙂

    Reply
  5. Andrew M. Warner says

    June 14, 2016 at 6:14 pm

    Hi Henneke,

    Great post here.

    You said something interesting here: “By managing distractions and my energy level, I slowly regained the ability to concentrate. To read rather than skim books. ”

    I have the most difficult time reading books now. I guess it has a lot to do with blogging, but it takes me a long time to finish one. And the reasons I struggle are just you explained.

    Just wanted to share that point because I’m amazed that you have that too.

    Anyhow, curiosity gaps are really key. I recently realized that the emails I sent all had generic, boring subject lines. The same things that many other people used and didn’t entice any curiosity from my subscribers.

    Recently, I changed it up and have a drastic increase in opens and clicks. So I’m a huge believer in curiosity gaps now.

    Also, I always loved the subject line “Do You Know This #1 Fiction Writing Trick For Compelling Business Content?” Really hooked me in and had me begging to find out what this trick was.

    Great job.

    – Andrew

    Reply
    • Henneke says

      June 15, 2016 at 12:26 pm

      To get back into reading books, I started with reading more fiction. In the evening, I would switch off my computer earlier and read ah hour before going to bed. Also, I often take a break in the afternoon to read.

      Once I got back into reading fiction, I started picking up fiction books again.

      I think get away from our computers is key! 🙂

      Great to hear you improved your opens and clicks so much, Andrew!

      Reply
  6. nathan says

    June 11, 2016 at 1:48 pm

    Hi Henneke,
    Very insightful post, thanks for sharing.
    It does seem that the curiosity factor helps a lot with getting emails to be clicked.
    I find that most of the email ists i am now subscribed to are adding a mystery factor so you click through.
    Explaining the way you have has certainly helped me understand what to write in my own emails.
    Thanks so much

    Reply
    • Henneke says

      June 11, 2016 at 6:54 pm

      Great! I’m glad you found it useful, Nathan 🙂

      Reply
  7. Rodney C. Davis says

    June 9, 2016 at 1:09 am

    This post is pure gold. I learned a thing or two about writing headlines years ago when blogging was still young. Those click-bait type ones worked OK back then. They don’t any more anyway. It’s a particularly important topic when your avatar is highly selective in what he clicks, but will commit to reading everything once the topic is relevant. I do believe this is the answer that’s been eluding me.

    Reply
    • Henneke says

      June 9, 2016 at 10:14 am

      I like the point you’re making about avatars being highly selective. I think more and more we see people getting weary – a feeling of “seen this – done that.” The other way to get around this might be ultra-specific headlines. Topics like punctuation, using adverbs, avoiding weak words seem to do well for me. It goes against the conventional blogging wisdom of addressing issues that keep readers awake at 3am. But it’s impossible to address such big issues (that keep people awake) week in week out anyway 🙂

      Reply
      • Rodney C. Davis says

        June 9, 2016 at 6:00 pm

        Thanks again, Henneke. The discussion touches on a larger issue about all marketing tactics–even the ones relying on lizard-brain responses. I remember reading Cialdini’s “Influence,” and quickly becoming less susceptible to marketing messages and tactics after becoming more aware. “Conventional blogging wisdom” has an ever-shorter life-cycle.

        Nowadays when a marketer targets me with a headline about what keeps me awake at night, I’m more likely NOT to click out of sheer backlash to the overuse of this approach. After a while, you can sense there are no easy solutions to complex problems to be found in any e-mail anyway. A growing number of people thus probably prefer to proactively seek out solutions to larger issues in an outbound fashion. For stuff in my in-box, the ultra specific headlines that help me to hone one avenue of my craft gets the nod each time.

        Reply
  8. Charles Emmanuel says

    June 2, 2016 at 11:52 pm

    Wow Henneke!

    This is noting but pure gold.

    And would fearlessly point out here that this idea deserves to be sold .

    Because let’s be honest.

    Powerful headlines are great for pulling readers in to our party of words…!

    But it’s not enough.

    To win the game and stand.out, We must entice and mesmerize our readers to click and subscribe to what we have to say.

    Not just that.

    We must find a way to enchant them so they’ll stay glude to our sentences. devouring every link like hungry lions geeding on preys.

    How?

    Open loops in email teasers.

    Because the truth is human brain is naturally designed to seek closure.

    As you pointed out Henneke, we all want answers and quick too. (sense of urgency)

    We all desire to see behind the wall. To stay to the end of the story. To see if anything appeals to our interest. Yes, it’s natural and we can’t possibly fight it.

    Loops will create that urgent atmosphere for action in our readers.

    Thanks again Henneke.

    Bold promise:

    I’ll share this post right away.

    Reply
    • Henneke says

      June 3, 2016 at 12:03 pm

      Hi Charles

      Thank you so much for stopping by, adding your thoughts and sharing the post. I appreciate it. I’m glad you enjoyed this one.

      Happy weekend!

      Reply
  9. barry says

    June 1, 2016 at 9:00 pm

    Hi There,

    Am I the only one that wonders what the judges said to the homeless guy? I certainly have a long way to go. Thanks for pointing me in the right direction.

    Barry

    Reply
    • Henneke says

      June 1, 2016 at 9:32 pm

      Nope, you’re not the only one. I wanted to find out, too.

      Out of the 5 Upworthy headlines, that was the one that appealed most to me.

      Reply
  10. Henry Truong says

    June 1, 2016 at 7:44 am

    I’m a very new blogger. I find the second type of curiosity inspiring me a lot. I’ll apply it for my next post.
    Thanks a lot for your article!

    Reply
    • Henneke says

      June 1, 2016 at 10:51 am

      Great! Thank you for stopping by, Henry

      Reply
  11. Julia Yvon says

    June 1, 2016 at 12:23 am

    Noted everything down. Thanks for the post.

    The following is no criticism. If I had to make only one click and were to choose between “A rover dived to the bottom of the ocean. 15 photos show what it found there” (example from this post) and “I prefer the Crazy Workload? This One Simple Question Calmed Me Down and Eased My Stress” (one of your posts’ title), the second layout instantly wins over the first one.

    Reading the second title, I feel the gap in knowledge. Reading the first one, I feel nothing but irritation and the urge to get away ASAP. Maybe it is a simple matter of taste. I’m an ocean lover. But I have an impression to be forced into reading the news that a) have nothing to do with me; b) more repulsive: are trying to appear sensational, while they are not. Nevertheless, if the title was changed to “Ever dived to the bottom of the ocean? Have a look”, I would click without hesitation.

    And the e-mail title “Do You Know This #1 Fiction Writing Trick For Compelling Business Content?”, as well as the e-mail itself, have everything I love. They sound personal, engaging.

    Reply
    • Henneke says

      June 1, 2016 at 10:51 am

      I’m not surprised you’d rather click “Crazy Workload? This One Simple Question Calmed Me Down and Eased My Stress.” The Upworthy headlines have become more and more associated with cheap content. We don’t expect an in-depth article when you click through anymore. It appeals to the distracting type of curiosity and we’ve learned that those articles leave us feeling unfulfilled and unsatisfied. We don’t really learn something.

      The “Crazy Workoad? This One Simple Question Calmed Me Down and Eased My Stress” is one of my favorite headline formulas!

      Reply
  12. Saleem Rana says

    May 31, 2016 at 8:50 pm

    Interesting. I never really thought about curiosity much.
    Let me see if I got this right?
    First, there is no curiosity. The reader is satisfied and doesn’t click through or read on.
    Second, there is empathetic curiosity. The reader feels acknowledged and wants to know more.
    Third, there is trivia curiosity. The reader wants to know what happened, but in the end it doesn’t really matter.
    Fourth, there is deepening curiosity. The reader whats to know how something works, finds out, and has a sense of fulfillment.
    Great article. Love you in-depth research.

    Reply
    • Henneke says

      June 1, 2016 at 10:43 am

      Empathetic curiosity is interest in learning about other people’s feelings. So, I’d say for readers that would be applicable if the reader is interested in understanding the author’s feelings, for instance because she shares her experience about dealing with fear or self-doubt.

      As bloggers, we probably don’t really deal with readers who have no curiosity at all. Readers pre-select themselves by joining a list – they want to learn more about a topic. So we don’t necessarily start from a situation of no curiosity at all. We tease people a little to click through but we’re already connecting with a curiosity they have already.

      If you’re interested in this topic, then I highly recommend Leslie’s book.

      Reply
  13. Carole Rains says

    May 31, 2016 at 8:30 pm

    I’m glad to read some tips on creating compelling subject lines. Marketing gurus often share their email templates, but without an enticing subject line we’re only getting half of the advice. Frankly, I think the subject line is even more important than the content, as long as you a providing something of value.

    P.S. Please don’t ever stop including your illustrations in your blog posts. They bring joy to my day 🙂

    Reply
    • Henneke says

      June 1, 2016 at 10:38 am

      Yep, I agree with you. Without a good subject line an email might not even get read.

      Good to see you again, Carole!

      Reply
  14. Ini says

    May 31, 2016 at 6:44 pm

    Thank you, Henneke. This post is very rich and insightful. I admire you for continually giving rich content at negligible cost to your readers. God bless you.

    Reply
    • Henneke says

      May 31, 2016 at 7:28 pm

      Thank you, Ini. I appreciate your comment.

      Reply
  15. Antoniya KZ says

    May 31, 2016 at 6:30 pm

    Another one of your golden posts, Henneke. I loved how simple but powerful your message and formula for creating curiosity is – desire + knowledge – and it makes so much sense in writing headlines.

    Thanks and hope you’re doing great 🙂

    Reply
    • Henneke says

      May 31, 2016 at 7:27 pm

      I hope you’re doing great, too, Antoniya! Thank you for your lovely comment 🙂

      Reply
  16. Kelly says

    May 31, 2016 at 5:13 pm

    Henneke,
    Timing is just right. I needed to read this today. Thank you. Kelly

    Reply
    • Henneke says

      May 31, 2016 at 6:15 pm

      You’re most welcome, Kelly. I wrote it for you! 🙂

      Reply
  17. Kitty Kilian says

    May 31, 2016 at 4:28 pm

    ‘By managing distractions and my energy level, I slowly regained the ability to concentrate.’
    > I think closing ourselves to the many online distractions may prove to be one of the biggest challenges we face.

    Reply
    • Henneke says

      May 31, 2016 at 6:15 pm

      Yes, I agree. The internet can destroy our curiosity for deepening our knowledge because it keeps serving us instant answers. We must resist, and nurture our ability to focus.

      Reply
  18. Sherman Smith says

    May 31, 2016 at 4:01 pm

    Hey Henneke,

    I was on a training a few years ago and trainer taught to sell the sizzle and not the steak. This goes right along with what your saying here.

    Getting that deeper knowledge is what we all want and just giving our readers hints and teasers will spruce up their curiosity even more. We are suppose to provide solutions but we want our readers to actually click on our articles to get those solutions. This becomes a win/win since we can write on topics more on what they’re most interested in and they get the answers they want.

    Thanks for the share . Have a good one!

    Reply
    • Henneke says

      May 31, 2016 at 6:13 pm

      Yep, so true. If we don’t get readers to click, then we don’t get a chance to share our insights!

      In the end, it always comes back to understanding what your reader wants to learn, doesn’t it?

      Reply
  19. Blake Smith says

    May 31, 2016 at 2:43 pm

    Hello Henneke,

    I enjoyed reading your post. Your email roused my curiosity and gave me something meaningful to think about. 😉 What makes this post stand out is its practical application. Thanks for sharing your insights and advice.

    Like you, I strive to write blog posts that go beyond instant gratification to deeper understanding of a topic. This can be a challenge in a world that thrives on the superficial.

    Reminds me of Brian Clark’s formula for writing irresistible content: meaning + fascination. The significance here is creating meaningful content. Then the writer uses curiosity (fascination) to motivate people to read further.

    One trend I’m sure you’re aware of is the fact that longer blog posts are shared and linked to more than shorter ones. Whether these longer posts actually get read is another matter. Perhaps this trend toward more in-depth posts is a reaction to the superficiality so common on the Internet.

    Blake Smith
    Web Content Doctor

    Reply
    • Henneke says

      May 31, 2016 at 6:12 pm

      Hello Blake

      Nice to see you here! 🙂

      I don’t really like the trend for longer blog posts, because most people write them for Google rather than for their readers. Often the posts are wordy and stuffed with information that’s not exactly relevant. The content loses focus, and feel sometimes more superficial than shorter posts. Of course, this is a generalization – it’s not always like that!

      I’ve stuck with writing posts around 1k words, and it seems to be serving me well. My search engine traffic is growing nicely, despite not spending much time on SEO at all (I don’t do any linkbuilding). Interestingly, the post currently receiving most organic search engine traffic is also one of my shortest at just over 750 words.

      Google wants us to write for our readers, so that’s what I do 🙂

      Reply
  20. neil simpson says

    May 31, 2016 at 2:41 pm

    The way I write is to share “insight” rather than “information”…

    …and the curiosity gap is opened by suggesting that the insight is useful available easily.

    🙂

    Reply
    • Henneke says

      May 31, 2016 at 6:05 pm

      Yep, that’s a good point! Insights rather than information.

      Thank you, Neil!

      Reply
  21. Katharine says

    May 31, 2016 at 1:58 pm

    Hi, Henneke!
    This has been such a helpful post! I don’t know how many times I’ve not even opened an email that promises shallow content. Yet, I could not put my finger on HOW not to be like them.
    Thanks so much for delineating it so clearly!
    And I know why your avid readers click right through: We know your content is dependably rich with valuable lessons aimed at making us shine. Every Tuesday I come to the Internet with one first aim, and it’s to see what you’ve posted, and not so much how to titled it. (Although, from now on, I’ll pay more attention, haha.
    If you entirely forgot to title a post, we’d still click through. 😉

    Reply
    • Henneke says

      May 31, 2016 at 6:05 pm

      What a lovely comment, Katharine. Thank you so much!

      I couldn’t figure out why exactly those clickbait titles were irritating either. Until I read Ian Leslie’s book…. who knew that there’s more kinds of curiosity?

      I feel lucky with loyal readers like you 🙂

      Reply
  22. Swadhin Agrawal says

    May 31, 2016 at 1:52 pm

    Hi Henneke,
    Really nice trick to get more open rates. I personally don’t like the buzzfeed type click bait headlines. They feel a way cheap and if you can’t meet the curiosity level yo might get a roof-shattering bounce rate.

    The other type, you talked about here, makes perfect sense and I believe will work. I am getting very low response to my emails and I think I should try this strategy.

    Thanks. 🙂
    -Swadhin

    Reply
    • Henneke says

      May 31, 2016 at 5:39 pm

      I agree with you. Those clickbait headlines feel cheap. I think that’s because we associate them with chasing clicks and sharing newsy titbits without furthering knowledge. They’re also written for scanners rather than readers.

      I hope you’ll enjoy trying out this strategy!

      Reply
  23. Anna Gunning says

    May 31, 2016 at 1:49 pm

    Hi Henneke,
    Thank you for this post!

    I get a lot of blog-promoting emails that use the headline as the subject line and then have an excerpt of the post. And I think that habit creates this pressure to be clickbait-y because you’re asking copy to do too many things.

    A reason I find your writing so persuasive is that I can tell each element is focused on getting me to take the next step. I think this approach is very liberating, because you don’t feel like you only have 5-10 words to create the curiosity gap. So looking at your email subject, email copy and blog headline – they all work together to entice and get me to read on without making the experience feel superficial.

    Reply
    • Henneke says

      May 31, 2016 at 5:37 pm

      Thank you so much for your lovely comment, Anna. I appreciate it.

      You’re right. I try to entice people to read on with every piece of content I create. Even on a level of sentences this works: the purpose of each sentence is to read the next sentence.

      I sometimes repeat the opening paragraph in the email. Sometimes it works. Sometimes it doesn’t feel right.

      Reply
  24. Amanda Nel says

    May 31, 2016 at 1:35 pm

    This is quite an interesting concept and by the looks of it, very effective. I am bookmarking this page to come back and try to implement your strategy! Thanks for sharing.

    Reply
    • Henneke says

      May 31, 2016 at 5:31 pm

      Yep, it works!

      Happy writing, Amanda!

      Reply
  25. Maggie says

    May 31, 2016 at 1:34 pm

    Great insights. Curious- what are your favorite fiction books?

    Reply
    • Henneke says

      May 31, 2016 at 5:31 pm

      The book I referred to in that email was “All the Light We Cannot See” by Anthony Doerr: https://www.enchantingmarketing.com/show-dont-tell/

      Reply
      • Maggie Carroll says

        May 31, 2016 at 5:43 pm

        A beautiful book. I went back and clicked through to the Fiction tip and saw your statements. Brilliant!!!
        I love this book and have recommended it widely. Not surprisingly, you have understood and clarified some of the technique that makes this book so special. Thank you for all of your work. As an engineer, I am not practiced in writing techniques. Your beautiful and simple explanations elegantly teach me techniques and concepts. Thank you. It takes more work to simplify, and I appreciate your art as well as your skill.

        Reply
  26. Kathy says

    May 31, 2016 at 1:34 pm

    I love how you clarify the difference between curiosity that involves growth and service to others, versus click-bait. Thanks for constantly being a leader in emphasizing marketing with integrity, and how to go about it.

    Reply
    • Henneke says

      May 31, 2016 at 5:35 pm

      The difference between the two types of curiosity only became clear to me after reading Ian Leslie’s book. Interestingly, in his book he mentioned “empathic curiosity” as another type of curiosity but I had written about that already last week (before I read his book).

      Thank you for your lovely comment, Kathy.

      Reply
  27. Virginia says

    May 31, 2016 at 1:05 pm

    Thanks for such an useful post. Click rates are a nightmare to me too. Thanks for gathering all these insights on the topic.

    Reply
    • Henneke says

      May 31, 2016 at 5:30 pm

      You’re welcome, Virginia. Thank you for stopping by!

      Reply
  28. Alison Beere says

    May 31, 2016 at 12:56 pm

    Hi Henneke

    “it’s the deepening of knowledge and sharing of our skills where the magic happens.”

    This post was the nourishing sort of click bait! I also like working in a zone where magic happens and people gain real skills that help them nurture themselves.

    I have been struggling with the emails I send out, trying to get the right balance between writing a whole blog post in them, and giving enough information so that people know what they will learn and how it will benefit them.

    It seems as though good headlines *must* have two parts: one which tells the reader what the email is about, and the second one which arouses their curiosity.

    Is this example that you have given the similar ‘formula’ for emails? i.e. curiosity, benefits, examples.

    This example you have included is one of your best recent emails, in my opinion (And I guess that is why you chose it today!) : it increases my curiosity by saying ‘it’s not storytelling’, then it tells me what I can do with what I learn, and finally also tells me what sort of examples to expect: sales copy, business writing and fiction.

    Reply
    • Henneke says

      May 31, 2016 at 5:27 pm

      On writing emails for blog posts, there are two schools of thought: one is to post the whole blog post in the email so people don’t have to click and the other is to only put enough in your email to make people to click through to your blog post. Some readers like reading longer content in an email, others prefer reading it as a blog post. Karyn Greenstreet has written a useful post about this: http://www.passionforbusiness.com/blog/email-marketing-include-full-articles-or-links/

      A good headline must provide a specific benefit explaining why people would read the post plus it much arouse curiosity. You don’t have to do this in separate parts; you can mix the two in one headline.

      And you’re right, the example email I included has seen one of the highest click rates this year. If possible, I try to increase curiosity and stress the benefits in my email. Sometimes it’s easier to arouse more curiosity than other times.

      I try not to make my emails to formulaic. While the ingredients are more or less the same, they don’t follow exactly the same pattern. In my experience, relying too much on the same pattern might make readers bored and might reduce click rates. I don’t have hard facts to prove this. It’s more a gut feeling based on what I’ve seen.

      Reply
      • Alison Beere says

        May 31, 2016 at 5:32 pm

        Thanks for such a comprehensive response, and for the extra information on that link. I am going to analyse my own click throughs based on how much / little I put in the email, and see if there is a correlation.

        I agree with the gut feel that a ‘formulaic’ approach to the mail can lead to reader fatigue. But it’s good to have an audit list, so that when I leave something out it’s intentional, not just an oversight 🙂

        Reply

Footer

Books and courses

Follow proven templates for specific writing tasks, practice your skills, and get professional feedback so you become a confident business writer. Take on any writing project with gusto.
Learn more about books and courses

About Henneke

I never saw myself as a writer, but in my early forties, I learned how to write and discovered the joy of writing. Now, I’d like to empower you to find your voice, share your ideas and inspire your audience.
Learn how I can help you

Popular topics

Sales copywriting

Blog writing for business

Your writing voice

Tips for beginning writers

The writing process

Improve your writing skills

Writing examples

Popular blog posts

Recent blog posts

Free Snackable Writing Course

Get 16 concise emails and learn how to write more persuasive content

Success! Now check your email to confirm your subscription.

There was an error submitting your subscription. Please try again.

Powered by Kit

Contact | Comment Policy | Privacy Statement | Terms and Conditions | Copyright © 2025 Enchanting Marketing Ltd.